chukiki

Why are u developers wasting money for people who are not good enough to play the game right? Running extra servers for a minority like that wastes so much money. Instead of less servers but better servers. Use the money on the better servers! I suggest just removing the "PVE" called server and save the money! Dont let ur game be destroyed by people who cant play the game right!

oh, boy he lost his base....why.... Hm, ever thought about that this is a survival game? git gud

mistake

2.3k hours and yet u havent played the game right... U were hiding behind a server that was protecting ur base. Git gud?!?

PVE Doesnt exist, whatever that is.THis game is a pirate game, not allowing to destroy ur opponents seems idiotic to me!We dont need extra servers for people who dont wanna play the game right.Pls remove!!!

skipped

yes I told them remove noensense custom building from land and sea, and give us whole ships and houses. The game performance is totally killed by custom buildings, people spam structures that consists of hundrets of pieces. And the buildings look ugly. And Building is not fun! No it is NOT! Having to rebuild my ship a hundret times or rebuilding my house and land defence isnt fun! It's repetitive. I want nordic, greek, chinese and egyptian cultural ready buildings and ships that u can just place and put ur stuff inside. THe whole nonesense building needs to go! Same wiht ships. Stupid custome building I hate it! Making ugly ships is creative!? No ur just being lazy, not wanting to design ships for us! To make this game look good, run smoothly and be fun, all custom building needs to be removed. But the reason why the game will never be great is the developers care only about money. They have no interest in making a great game. They think like this: Ok how do we make more people buy our game? Ok, lets add some gimmicks (dolphin riding, seahorse riding, animal hats, decorated boats etc.) that will attract new customers! Yepp, thats how they think. Thats why they havent fixed any bugs. And are not going to because in their mind it is "why waste time on fixing bugs, when people are dumb enough to keep playing our games the way it is" Their whole focus is on gaining new buyers, they believe we are already stupid enough to keep playing their buggy mess. So nothing is fixed, only gimmick has been added. And they remove people from the forum, that speak those things out! That's why the majority of the forum users are all big company worshipping followers. Thats the people that are left here. People like u and me are the minority here, even though we are indeed the MAJORITY if u get what im saying! Even though Atlas is a pirate game, the ship designs and battle mechanics are horrible! Even android games do a better job than Atlas at this:

Update confirms my demands! I also updated my animal section in this list

I was quite surprised seeing an update that wouldn't worsen the game.Thats the first time I have to say something positive about the game. Well done! And actually in this update the developers prooved they were listening to me. Adding cupboards (claim towers) was my idea. This patch went into the right direction. So im glad about the patch. Unfortunately there is still too much bad stuff in the game that makes the game unenjoyable, mainly unbalanced sea and land PVP. Until they havent removed the BAR SHOT from the game and increased cannon ball flying speed, I cant enjoy sea battles. Im not willing to head out wiht a galleon I spent 2hours building for getting crippled by a little schooner just because he uses overpowered Barshots. A schooner schould have 0 chance against a galleon! Until they havent removed BAR SHOTS from the game I wont play the game! Back to the update, great update. I could steal some big ships, which was quite fun. I wish we could steal animals too. I stole a galleon with 30 animals, mostly horses, in it. yet I couldnt make use of them, had to kill them all... what a waste! These horses should be MINE!!!!! After a day or so they should be converted to my company. It doesnt make sense if u steal a pet that it wont listen to u. It needs food and u feed it, so it would listen. THere are some bug wiht the claim towers. If u are in the radius of a claim tower that u just destroyed u lose parts of ur ship to the enemy company! So that needs fix.

wanna find a new game with me? I think im almost done with it

if 20 people hit a rock, they gather at the same speed as a solo player. if it's half of 5 , lets say 2.5 u can easily make it 2 instead and save the 0.5, so next hit it adds up to 5. Sorry but I seriously question ur intelligence. Like How can a brain be so limited, haha THere is no reason for one team gathering faster than the other, thats unfair and not what we want. And for every little problme is a solution. U guys are just trying to find holes in my method because ur fucking jealous and too cowardish to admit my idea is great., Nacona ur being ignored now.

r u born close minded or sth>? I just said my method solves eveyrthing. 3 random people attacking each other, they all have to attack both players, otherwise it turns into a 2vs1, thats exactly what my method tries to avoid. Im done talking wiht u, have a good day and stay narrowminded

And like I feel ur hard core narrow minded that just doesnt want changes. The small issues casn be later fixed. The biggest issue that is clans, my method wonderfully solves. Gtfo

like i said, 2 enemy players fighting, whjile neithor of them is hitting the other one means = fighitng side by side. thats easy detectable 3 random people attacking each other is an unfair fight, r u even aware of it? Thats exactly what my method solves

lol, let them ally, they get penalties. 2 allies = each of them half the ressource gather rate, crew member size etc. all mentioned above. And if they secretly ally, they cant realy fight side by side, bc the game can make it they take damage per/second THx for mentionign this, ill add it, haha ~!

updated

if u knew how much shit big companies have... oh my boy. This game is extremely favorable towards big company, they make certain items extra hard (islands, ships, quests) so that the big clans have everything and solo players have nothign because these things are too hard to aquire solo. And they even make big clans invincible by giving them indestructable armored docks and peace time islands, so that not even the hard core solo player filled in rage can revenge on a company that is sleeping (offline). They added coins for ships that u little man cannot harm the big guys. And Armored dokcs so that u little man cant sink their ships while they're sleeping. It's simple as that. The dev must be playing in big clans themselves so they dont want small boys to be able to compete with them.

Ill always update this list

I was told that if u split a team on ur own island. And let that other team pay taxes, they get the full 100%, and the tax collecter also get 30% of it??? So basically if a clan does it it gets 130% I was told. HOW FUCKED UP IS UR GAME!>?!?!?

-Armored docks need to be removed from the game: Whats the point of a pirate game if u cant even destroy ur opponents ships when raiding?! People just put all their loot into their ship and gold into the armored dock, and their stuff is safe. That's dumb. There is no point in raiding if u cant get people's loot. Remove them or massively reduce their HP to like 500k. -puckle npc's need to be vulnerable the game needs smart AI that u buy and is already equipped with weapons, and can respawn given u have the gold, with a respawn cool down。 We need smart AI, no need for insta kill swivel gun AI and Puckle. Let people fight on ships with weapons in their hand like real pirates did. -gold cost for self crafted ships needs to be removed gold coins just make the boat crafting unnessarily grindy and it is unrealistic. -no gun mini game it's just a horrible idea -HP of shipyards needs to be lowered they are too cheap for what they endure. And ofc people abuse this fact and spam them along the coast as a barricade -Lighthouses are too cheap they are too cheap compared to the HP they have, hard to take out and too easy to build -mortars on ships need to be allowed to counter mortars on land they need to be rebalanced and be allowed to be place on ships, whether they do damage to other ships, u have to figure out. But attacking a base with ur ship and being attacked by mortars on land, u on ur ship have no option to counter them at the moment. If land has mortars, ships need as well otherwise it's unfair -ships should be insta captured if beds are destroyed, and ship is decrewed Thats right! Its not a pirate game if u cant capture ships. U kill the crew on board u take his ship! U can reduce the countdown to max 10 to 20min, not longer! Nobody is willing to kill somebodies crew and wait for 2 full days!!! And this game is plane boring if u cant capture ship. The whole point of being a pirate is to plunder and capture ships. -structures must be capturable Nobody shouldnt be able to own anything, so u can move into anybodies range if u own their (cupboard, like in Rust) Thats one solution. The big problem in Atlas right now is u cant capture buildings, and people spam stone pillars everywhere to prevent people from building there. Sticks are so cheap and to take them out wiht cannon balls takes hours. Cupboards would be more expensive and people can take over bases that way. -small characters should get a speed penalty, while super large ones get a damage buff most people choose midget size for their characters because their harder to hit wiht ranged weapons. This is an abuse and should be fixed. Either dont allow midgets or give them a speed penalty (small characters move slower). The smaller u are the slower you move. -cannons need to be pick-up-able and be placable on enemy foundation to raid efficiently what a waste of material for the raider. Thats unfair and is plain unfair! U should be able to pick up ur cannon. -fix that bug where after u use praying eyes u cant pull out ur weapons, and increase duration fix -remove peace/combat phases totally unrealistic and lame. Everybody should be able to be attacked whenever people decide to. Peace and combat phase system is just nonesense and killing the fun of the game. The thrill of the game is when u dont know when ur opponent attacks u. Peace and combat phases kill that uncertainty. -blueprints need to be removed they add nothing new to the game, it's just a numbers change in stats. Add new weapons or clothes if u want improved versions. Changing numbers is just lame. And the blueprints imbalances the game even more. -aging/hair growth is way too fast atm there's no fun in being old in a couple days again right after u went to the fountain of youth -remove shaking earth effect caused by animals it's annoying -no more crew limits on ships U should be able to board as much crew as u want -remove all chores like treasure hunting, floatsam etc. from the game repetitive, boring, slowing down the traveling -players shouldnt spawn on freeports, and freeport, there shouldnt be a safe zone same with the armored dock, total safety sucks, takes out the thrill. U can give freeports towers to defend or something, but dont just make them safe... Everyone will just store his loot there in their boats including animals -nerf barrels I heard they are too strong, and i felt they were quite strong once. Dont add money to them. -remove ships of the damned super annoying, and this is a multiplayer game, not a single player. NPCs have no business to be there in such large amount. Especially these ships should be very rare or not even there at all. -regarding animals: Horses are too strong. They shouldn't be able to fight other animals and humans. That's unrealistic and makes them overpowered. They also have too much HP. Remove their leveling and torpor damage. The rider should fight with his sword/lance etc. not use the horse to hit other creatures, thats nonesense. Elephants have too low weight capacity. Lions make annoying noise when jumping. Lions cant take enemies off their mounted animals nor even hurt them. Some horses are level 100+ people upgrade their HP, a lion then can neither grab the rider from its horse nor can the lion do as much damage as fast as the rider can heal the horse! Animals shouldnt be upgradable, that ur horse becomes a tank and kills a tiger just because it is level 70 and the tiger is level 30. Remove all upgrades from animals! Or simply fix it, make their upgrades tiny and add speed upgrades or whatever, figure it out! Razertooth cant jump, why?!?! -nerf mace, shield stun, buff crossbow/bow/guns, nerf shield, nerf hook pvp a joke in this game. ranged weapons do too low damage (esp. vs armor) plus players are able to upgrade their HP. And Mace is utter bullshit OP as well as some dirty ridiculous stuff like using the hook against players - what a joke is this??? Hook should never be used against people thats such nonesense! And guns are also bad. Too little damage. And remove shield bashing or make it a one time use wiht a cooldown, same wiht the fist power punch that stuns the enemy every time. -Handcuffs need to be removed or there needs to be a solution they are too overpowered in certain situations for example if u r getting raided u cant even face ur opponents in melee fight because u r too scared to to fall into their hands and be hand cuffed. Thjen u can see ur base being raided while u cant do anything. Also handcuffs can be used in a abusive way. People can literally keep being caged for hours. Either remove handcuffs completely or find another way! This feature is absolutely abusable and very bad! -Cannon balls fly too slow another factor that turns sea fights into horseshit. They fly too slow and thus are able being dodged by simply stopping the boat and accelerating it. -after destroying a warehouse you should get all the loot inside, not a fraction unrealistic and bullshit. Give all loot!!! ur just grieving the raider. Maybe ur personal hatred or ur scared about a few people leaving the game that cant stand losses. Babies... -bar shots need to be removed utter idiotical overpowered horse crap ammunition that ruins sea pvp. All sea fights are determined by this ammunition. -no character upgrades like HP etc. level 120 player vs player level 10. Nakeds killing another player fully armored just because they are level 120 with 300 HP. Total bullshit! -player name join notification needs to be removed it gives away players information and that is not good, u want to be anonymous to not let ur enemies know when ur in the same grid and when not -customizable zoom for ships needs to be added people want to be able to zoom out more -remove customizable ships u shouldnt be able to build on ur ship, it's not land, u cant just build a house on it!!! It looks dumb and it makes pvp unrealistic. People build towers on their ships to get more range and place like 6 cannons on the back to shoot backwards on top of a tower, thats just sheer stupidity. Dont allow construction on ships. Give us ready ships, that we can craft their parts for and add some attachments on it. The custom building on ships is one of the reasons why ship fights are so unrealistic and stupid and it needs to go! -increase ship weight capacity it's too punishing having a couple cannons on your ship, having the bare minimum of cannons is already too much. Increase overall max weight capacity of all ships! Besides cannons should all weight not more than 40kg, no matter where they are placed -remove limits for alliances and company size whos friend with who and how many u dont decide! -handling sails get greatly outperformed by speed sails they're just too slow, even against the wind speed sails still beat them! -wood/stone pillars's HP needs to be reduced People spam these pillars all over their island so nobody can build while it takes 20 cannon ball shots to take out just one!!! Holy crap, it isnt a stone wall for fuck sake! Lower their HP so 1 cannon ball is enough to destroy a stone pillar! -remove ownership buildings, ships should be capturable just by bording it. There should be no ownership. At the moment one person is the owner, and can basically kick all members and claim all stuff for himself. Thats totally abusable. Imagine a clan of 20 members, they have 30 galleons and what not and the owner one day decides to kick everybody. What a horrible scenario! This whole ownership is so dumb and needs to go! Ownership on animals makes sense, but the rest not! It needs to be like in Rust where there are cupboards. 1 person should never have that much power to own it all and be able to grief a group. And nothing is capturable at the moment. U cant conquer bases or ships, u have to wait till the players leave and their base auto decays. Just a complete horseshit system! -reduce gather rate and adjust prices A 2x2 thatch house should take 10 min to build. A 2x2 wood house should take 20 min to build. A 2x2 stone house should take 40 min to build. This will prevent building spam. If players lose a building it should hurt! Also making a stone house should be an accomplishment people can be proud of. -remove custom building It totally ruins the game! It looks ugly, it wastes time, it's not fun and it is unrealistic. People build fucking bunkers in the pirate age, like wtf!?! Remove this cancerous building system and replace it with prebuilt buildings. Let us choose from a row of houses, castles, towers which one to place. And make it 3 cultures, so the player can actually choose his building style. Same with boats, allow nordish/egyptian/asian ships. The game build should work as in a strategy game, where u just place buildings based on ur ressources and skills. Remove the cancerous custom build from land and ships! -allow saving ships (save + load) building the same ship over and over is tedious and wastes time. Allow us to save our own ships so that we just need to put the right ressources into the dock to make them at once. -remove towers that give buffs to ships benefits clans only, and is very silly by design Reduce a companies income based on their member number, increase crew cost for bigger clans 1. The more member it has the less each member gathers. So let's say if they are 20 people, 1 player only gathers 1/20th of what a solo player gathers. This garantees the equal ressource income of 1 player vs 20 players. It can be compared to a strategy game where 1 player controls 1 faction, and 20 players control alltogether another faction. These 20 players still have the advantage of being able to build faster bc they can devide their work, but at least both factions have the same ressource income. This will make sure that all companies have the same ressource gather capacity! 2. Increase amount of gold cost per crew member based on company size. Lets say 1 player can afford 20 crew members, for the same gold cost a 20 player clan can only afford 1 crew member. The result is an equal force of 21 vs 21 players. The bots bought need to be strong as a player. So the AI needs to be improved. If u cant make them smarter just give them more HP and attack, because we all know the current AI is stupid af and unable to compete with real human players. Same for Sea fights. A player can buy AI ships similar to the ships of the damned, that have HP. These AI ships can follow the player similar to tamed animals on land. This change will equal out forces! Same goes for allies. So If they ally (split clan into smaller companies) and ally, each company's gather rate will be halved. If they secretly ally (means not officially), and they fight side by side, the game will recognize that two enemy forces are next to each other while not either side is taking any damage caused by the other player and the players will lose their HP/sec by a certain amount. Same goes for ships, u cant have enemy ships nearby, while not fighting. After a certain time they take damage. If 3 random people are attacking each other, each of them has to attack both players, otherwise he'll take damage, so it is never a 2vs1. -Remove all servers called "PVE" it devides the community. And people who cant play the game right because they are not good enough should just leave. This is a pirate game not a baby game.

remove

remove

GOLD FOR SHIPS, ARMORED DOCKS, STUPID TRADE HAS TO GO

ok i black sheeps like the above , dont comment on my threads ull get ignored anyways

-Armored docks need to be removed from the game -puckle npc's need to be vulnerable -gold cost for self crafted ships needs to be removed -farmhouses need to be removed -no dmg penalty (ship classes) -no gun mini game -HP of shipyards needs to be lowered -a lot of special buildings are too cheap (light house, shipyards etc.) -ridden animals should auto attack -no more cool down on recently placed cannons -ships should be insta captured if beds are destroyed -structures must be capturable -small characters should get a damage penalty, while super large ones get a damage buff\ -cannons need to be pick-up-able and be placable on enemy foundation to raid efficiently -fix that bug where after u use praying eyes u cant pull out ur weapons, and increase duration -remove peace/combat mode -blueprints need to be removed -aging/hair growth way too fast -remove shaking earth effect caused by animals -no more ship crew limits -remove all chores like treasure hunting etc. from the game -players shouldnt spawn on freeports, and freeport, there shouldnt be a safe zone -remove gold cost from explosive barrels -remove ships of the damned -no more treasure maps -horses are too slow, elephants start with too little HP and weight capacity -nerf mace, shield stun, buff sword -crossbow needs severe damage upgrade -Cannon balls are too slow, and ships accelerate/stop too fast so that they can simply dodge all shots. -after destroying a warehouse you should get all the loot inside, not a fraction -bar shots need to be removed -no character upgrades like HP etc. -player name join notification needs to be removed -Tiger/lion remove his noise when he jumps