I’ve seen many arguments about this topic and I see both perspectives. But the fact is without any sort of offline Protection new players simply won’t stay, when someone spends 6-12 hours of their spare time every day farming and building just to log on the next day and everything is gone and destroyed from an offline raid is infuriating. It’s not the fact that people destroyed the base or ships it’s the fact it was done while they were unable to protect themselves. If I lost a brig or a galleon in a ship fight I wouldn’t mind, they won fair and square but if someone sees my ship anchored and destroys it while I’m sleeping or at work then all I’m doing every day is wasting my time. There’s no progress when you gotta start from scratch every time you log on. The game has huge potential but requires my buildings and ships to be safe while I’m busy trying to live an actual life. A simple Protection timer would do fine, it could activate 15 minutes after logging off to prevent it being exploited in actual pvp fights and it can last 3-4 days and after that time is over then bases and ships can be destroyed while the players are offline. Something along these lines would work, but in its current state official servers simply aren’t fun for new players.